Ph. D.-Theses (since 1990) : Summaries
Analysis of nonconducting materials by means of GDMS using the secondary cathode technique. WIM SCHELLES, 1996
Glow discharge mass spectrometry (GDMS) has developed in the past decade as
an important tool for (ultra)trace analysis of solid conducting samples. Its
main advantages are the low limits of detection (down to sub ppb level), its
rather uniform elemental sensitivity and its ability to measure all elements and
even isotopes (unlike, for example, X-ray techniques). The sample is exposed to
a low pressure discharge and is actually sandblasted, on atomic scale, by
particles (ion and neutrals) present in this plasma.
Because the material
under investigation acts as a cathode in the discharge, one of the main
challenges for glow discharge spectroscopy is to overcome the intrinsic
requirement of the sample to be electrically conducting. The above mentioned
interesting analytical figures of merit and the increasing need for nonconductor
analysis (e.g. ceramics) are major motivations to investigate possible ways to
extend the applicability of GDMS towards insulating materials. Up to now, three
approaches have been used for nonconductor analysis.
In the case of powder
samples, one can bring the nonconductor into a high purity conducting host
matrix (e.g. copper powder) and electrodes can be pressed from the resulting
powder mix. However, when the sample to be analyzed in investigation is a solid
material, like a plate of sintered ceramic material, grinding can be troublesome
and, moreover, can cause serious contamination. For these sample types two other approaches, avoiding any sample preparation, are more appropriate.
One
method involves the use of a radio frequency powered (rf) glow discharge. The
main advantage of the rf source is the possibility to atomize electrically
nonconducting solid samples directly, without exposing any auxiliary conductor
to the discharge. During the last years, this source has gained, rightly,
increasing interest. However, at this moment, no commercial rf glow discharge
mass spectrometer is available.
As an alternative for rf GDMS, also direct
current (dc) GDMS can be used for the direct analysis of solid nonconductors.
This is made possible by the use of a secondary cathode or mask. The flat sample
under examination is exposed to the glow discharge through the aperture (3 - 10
mm) of a conducting diaphragm, called the secondary cathode. According to the
theory suggested by Milton and Hutton, who first applied this technique
successfully for the analysis of glass, a thin conducting film is formed on that
part of the nonconducting sample that is in contact with the plasma. This is a
consequence of the continuous, in situ, sputter-redeposition of secondary
cathode material. When the redeposited layer is thinner than the sampling
thickness, it can be penetrated by the bombarding particles. The effective
atomization of the nonconducting sample is thus dependent on the appropriate
thickness of the conducting layer: a too thin or incomplete layer causes
discharge instabilities due to the charge built-up on the sample surface, while
an excess of redeposition will prevent the bombarding particles from reaching
the nonconductor to be analyzed. Because the relative redeposition is
proportional to the discharge pressure, Milton and Hutton considered the
pressure as (only) determining parameter in the building of the conducting
layer.
In this project, the secondary cathode technique has been further
evaluated, based on the limited investigation presented by Milton and Hutton. We
have focused on two different aspects of the secondary cathode technique: first
the methodological aspects are thoroughly examined; second, several novel
applications have been performed with this technique.
It has been shown by
Milton and Hutton and confirmed by our own experiments that specific operating
conditions are required to obtain successful atomization of a nonconducting
sample. Moreover, we have noticed that these optimum conditions seemed not to be
the same for all the samples under investigation. An attempt is made to get a
better insight in the varying parameters involved in the formation of the
conducting layer.
First, some sample characteristics, in particular the
electrical resistivity and the specific surface properties have been evaluated.
The effect of the electrical resistivity was significant but has only to be
taken into account to classify samples as "poorly conducting" or
"nonconducting". It was found that samples with a specific electrical
resistivity smaller than ca. 5.109 cm could directly be used as cathode to
initiate and maintain a stable discharge, without exposing an auxiliary
conductor (for example a secondary cathode) to the discharge. The obtained
sample signal intensity was, however, found to be reversely proportional to the
electrical resistivity of the sample. This means that, for samples with an
electrical resistivity close to the edge of 5.109 cm, the sample signal
intensity can become extremely low (5.10-16 A). In these cases, the use of a
secondary cathode has found to be able to enhance the signal intensity with a
factor of 105, to a level that is almost comparable to the intensities reached
for conducting samples. Above a critical edge of conductivity (ca. 1.1010 cm)
samples become actually completely "nonconducting". This means that no discharge
at all can be obtained when samples of this type are used. The use of a
secondary cathode is in this case absolutely necessary to create a stable
discharge. The difference between "poorly conducting" and "nonconducting"
samples has significant consequences. The analysis of poorly conducting samples
displays a higher sample signal intensity and a lower contribution of the
secondary cathode, resulting in limits of detection that are a factor of ca.
10-20 better than for truly nonconducting samples.
Another sample
characteristic that has been evaluated is the surface roughness. It has been
demonstrated that the atomization of a sample with a rough surface requires more
deposited metal atoms (i.e. a higher discharge pressure) than that of a sample
with a smooth surface. This is to be expected, because a rough surface exhibits
a larger area exposed to the discharge than a smooth surface.
A third factor
that appeared to have a possible influence is generally termed as the affinity
between the sample and the deposited metal atoms. It has been shown that samples
with a comparable electrical resistivity and a comparable surface roughness can
require other discharge conditions to obtain stable atomization of the
nonconducting sample. This can plausibly be addressed to differences in surface
affinity; analogous observations have been made in the field of plasma
deposition techniques.
Second, besides the sample characteristics, also
several operating parameters have to be taken into account. The secondary
cathode material is of most importance, both because of its sputter yield and
because of the impurities present in it. The sputter yield should be low, to
prevent an excess of redeposited metal atoms on the nonconducting sample. Only
Ta was found to be useful as secondary cathode material for the analysis of
truly nonconducting samples. Care has to be taken in choosing the Ta secondary
cathode material (manufacturer and even batch).
The secondary cathode
geometry can also be considered as a factor determining the final analytical
performance of the technique. For the analysis of truly nonconducting samples,
the secondary cathode aperture had to be restricted to 4-5 mm, in order to
create a stable discharge. The thickness of the secondary cathode is of
importance as well. Thin secondary cathodes (ca. 0.25 mm thickness) are
preferable to reach low limits of detection, because of the higher sample signal
intensity and the lower contribution of the secondary cathode in the mass
spectrum. However, because the thickness of the secondary cathode indirectly
also influences the crater obtained, deviation of this general rule may be
useful in cases of depth profiling.
Evidently, also the influence of the
discharge conditions was evaluated. Here, it has to be emphasized that, in
contrast to the theory suggested by Milton and Hutton, not only the pressure is
of importance, but also the discharge current and the discharge voltage have to
be taken into account in the evaluation of the formation of an appropriate
conducting layer on the nonconducting sample.
Generally, one can state that
several parameters have to be considered together to reach a maximum sample
signal intensity and a minimum secondary cathode signal contribution.
After
the methodological evaluation of the secondary cathode concept, in order to
investigate how to sputter-atomize various sample types, the analytical
performance of the technique is described in Chapter 4. The technique has been
applied to various nonconducting matrices: glass plates, an iron ore sinter,
marble and limestone, ceramic materials (Al2O3, ZrO2 and Macor ceramic),
polymers (polytetrafluoroethylene or Teflon, polycarbonate, polyvinylchloride
and polyimide) and, after slight adaptation of the technique, also atmospheric
particulate matter.
First, it is important to notice that almost all these
materials could successfully be analyzed with dc GDMS using the secondary
cathode technique. Only the limestone (because of its too rough surface) and the
polyvinylchloride (because of its low melting point) could not be analyzed in a
stable way. In all other cases, the reproducibility was at the order of 10% RSD.
Second, the obtained signal intensities were found to be between 2.10-12 and
5.10-11 A. Given that peaks of ca. 1-5.10-18 A can be distinguished from the
background, this results in a practical power of detection between 20 ppb and 1
ppm. However, spectral interferences can, for certain elements, increase the
limits of detection. Moreover, sputtering of the secondary cathode material
results in a certain blank contribution that can also largely affect the power
of detection. Third, it was found that satisfying semi-quantitative data (within
a factor of 3) were obtained, based only on one internal standard and no
external standards.
Compared to rf GDMS (i.e., the technique that is also
capable of handling solid nonconducting samples without grinding them), the
above mentioned blank contribution is probably the major drawback. Fortunately,
this can only be considered as a limiting factor for about 15 % of the elements.
Another obvious disadvantage of the secondary cathode technique is that the
discharge conditions cannot be chosen freely and that the required conditions
can differ from matrix to matrix. Searching the optimum discharge conditions can
demand some trial-and-error experiments but this is a once-only problem.
However, for depth profiling purposes, the limited discharge conditions can
really expose a problem, because the shape of the crater (ideally rectangular)
can hardly be varied. For this application, rf GDMS certainly seems more
interesting.
On the other hand, the secondary cathode technique has also a
definite advantage in comparison with rf GDMS. The signal intensities do not
depend on the thickness of the sample, a problem that has been, up to now,
inherent to the use of rf GDMS. Moreover, the rf GDMS equipment is much more
complex and more expensive than the use of a simple diaphragm.
Generally, the
use of the secondary cathode can be considered as a viable alternative for rf
GDMS, unless there are specific requirements. Especially for those researchers
who are already using dc GDMS equipment, the secondary cathode technique can be
very interesting. It largely extends their area of application without having an
extra cost or a significant change of operating procedures.
Weathering of monuments by natural and air pollution factors: a study using trace-, isotopic- and micro-analysis. KARLIEN TORFS, 1997
Stable isotope measurements are a useful tool in determining the source of a
certain element. Sulphur isotope analyses are regularly utilized to identify the
origin of sulphate in rainwater and aerosols and of atmospheric SO2, but only
seldom to explain stone deterioration phenomena.
Various kinds of samples
were taken in the region around Antwerp, Belgium : in the centre of the city, in
the harbour (north of the centre) and in the surrounding area. Stone crusts were
gathered, atmospheric SO2 was sampled, rainwater was monitored and fume exhausts
of several anthropogenic emitters were studied (a power plant, oil refineries,
...). The isotopic composition was measured using an isotope ratio mass
spectrometer, after converting the samples into SO2.
Relatively large
variations of the 34S/32S ratio have been found in gypsum crusts on monuments
situated in the centre of Antwerp, the suburbs and the surrounding area. More
heavy sulphur is encountered in the centre of the town. This variation may be
caused by the importance of other SO2 sources resulting in an enrichment of
34S
in the weathering crusts in the centre of the city. The variation in S isotopic
composition of the crusts coincide geographically with the variation of SO2 in
the atmosphere, but generally. The petrochemical industry in the harbour is
supposed to be the major SO2 emitter in the north of Antwerp, while in the
southern region, the local brickyard industry influences the isotopical
composition of SO2 and the weathering layers on stone.
Characterization of individual aquatic suspended particles using Electron Probe X-ray Microanalysis and Scanning Transmission Electron Microscopy. WENDY JAMBERS, 1997
A review of literature has shown that micro-analytical techniques have hardly
been used to characterize individual suspension in aquatic environments. The
majority of the publications discuss the results of analyses of samples
collected, in the frame of the GEOSECS project, in the Pacific and Atlantic
Ocean and of samples collected in different rivers in Western Europe. However in
some continents, like South-America and Africa, and in large regions, like the
Middle-East and the former USSR, individual aquatic particles have never been
characterized.
The majority of these single particle analyses have been
performed using automated electron probe X-ray micro-analysis (EPXMA) and
scanning electron microscopy combined with energy dispersive X-ray detection
(SEM-EDX). Thanks to this automation, large numbers of particles can be analysed
in a reasonable period of time, resulting in an improved accuracy for the
characterization of the particles. However, these techniques can only give
information about the chemical composition of the particles. This limitation was
circumvented by using manual EPXMA and scanning transmission electron microscopy
- selected area electron diffraction combined with EDX (STEM-EDX-SAED) in
addition to the automated EPXMA measurements. These additional analyses reveal
information about the morphological and crystalline structure of the particles.
Another problem encountered during automated EPXMA measurements is the
difficulty to analyse organic particles. This can be solved by staining the
samples with ruthenium tetroxide (RuO4), which is a strong oxidizing agent that
reacts with most organic compounds. This staining results in an increase of the
effective average atomic number of the elements in the organic particles and
thus a higher BSE signal, necessary for detection during automated
EPXMA.
These automated analyses result in huge data matrices, which have to
be reduced for interpretation. This reduction was preformed using factor
analysis and hierarchical clustering combined with selection rules. In earlier
studies, hierarchical clustering was always combined with a secondary clustering
of the groups resulting from the first one, but this combined clustering is very
time consuming. Tests on the classification using clustering followed by
selection rules or using only selection rules have proven that both give
comparable results. Selection rules can only be applied when some information
about the chemical composition of the data is available, but this information
can be obtained using the relative X-ray intensities of common minerals present
in suspension and the results of the primary clustering. This combination of
hierarchical clustering and selection rules can be used to reduce the data
matrices of samples without prior knowledge of the chemical composition of the
samples. The data of the automated analyses were also used to obtain size
distributions of the different particle types and to calculate the TSP values of
the samples.
Before STEM-EDX-SAED could be used for the characterization of
suspended particles, the camera constant necessary to calculate the lattice
spacings of the crystalline structure, and the imaging system had to be
calibrated using standard materials. Because this technique had never been used
for the characterization of suspension present in seawater, also the sample
preparation had to be optimised. Studies on freshwater samples have revealed
that embedding of the particles in the hydrophilic Nanoplast resin and direct
centrifugation of the particles onto the electron microscopy (EM)-grid are the
preparation techniques which induce minimal physicochemical and physical
transformations of the particles. Because Nanoplast embedding produced the
smallest numbers of artefacts, this approach was the first to be tested on North
Sea samples. Unfortunately, sea salt crystallized not only as individual
particles, but also as coatings on natural suspended particles, resulting in
interferences in the diffraction patterns of these particles. Crystallized sea
salt was also present after direct centrifugation, but the amount of coated
particles was limited. Thus direct centrifugation onto an EM-grid is the best
preparation technique for STEM-EDX-SAED analyses of suspended particles present
in seawater.
Suspended particles, collected during the different seasons at
ten locations and three depths in the Southern Bight of the North Sea, have been
individually characterized using EPXMA and STEM-EDX-SAED. The composition of the
suspended particles was relatively constant in place and time. Only during high
primary production a different composition was obtained. All suspension samples
were dominated by aluminosilicate, Ca-containing and Si-containing particles
(mean abundance of over 95%). The aluminosilicates were mainly of mineral
origin; diffraction analyses revealed the presence of biotite and chloritoid,
but also a limited number of anthropogenic fly-ash particles were detected.
Ca-containing and Si-containing particles had a dominant mineral source, but
biogenic particle were also important contributors to these particle types,
especially during periods of primary production. The majority of the Fe-rich
particles were found to have a mineral source, while Ti-rich particles were
identified as polycrystalline rutile and brookite, which are both of
anthropogenic origin. Staining of the samples with RuO4 has confirmed the
presence of an organic coating on all suspended matter in natural waters.
However, the amount of organic matter present in the particles varied with the
seasons. Biogenic and trace metal particles always contained large amounts of
organic material, but during primary production in spring Fe-rich, Ca-rich,
Si-rich and aluminosilicate particles also hold large amounts of organic matter.
This Ru-staining not only revealed that only half of the organic particles are
detected during automated analyses of unstained samples, but it also showed that
some trace metal rich particles and aluminosilicates have too low backscatter
electron (BSE) signals to be detected in the unstained samples. It can thus be
concluded that the total suspended matter can only be characterized after
staining of the sample. A detailed study of the trace metal containing particles
revealed that the majority were natural Mn-containing particles, but also
significant contributions of Cr-containing and Ni-containing particles were
detected. The Cr-containing, Ni-containing and Zn-containing particles were
mainly associated with organic particles, while manganese was mainly present as
a coating on minerals. Comparison of the total suspended particulate matter
(TSP) of the Ru-stained and unstained samples revealed that the amount of
organic particles was small during winter and summer and large and more variable
during primary production. Due to the influence of wind force and wind
direction, the total amount of TSP was three times higher in autumn and winter
compared to summer and spring.
During the sampling campaigns on the North Sea
also rainwater samples were collected. The particulate phase was characterized
using EPXMA, while the dissolved fraction was analysed using inductively coupled
plasma - optical emission spectroscopy (ICP-OES), ICP-mass spectrometry
(ICP-MS) and ion chromatography (IC). The suspension was dominated by natural
aluminosilicates, organic and Si-rich particles, but also relatively high
abundances were found for the Fe-rich and Ti-rich particles, which both mainly
originated from anthropogenic sources. For two successive samples, collected in
the port of Ipswich, a significant decrease was noticed in the TSP value,
particles size and abundance of coarse aluminosilicate particles. During the
first shower, the coarse particles, mainly present underneath the cloud, are
washed out, resulting in a dominance of smaller rainout particles during the
second shower. Above sea, the amount of TSP is much smaller and more variable
than above land and the differences in washout and rainout between successive
samples is less visible. This is most likely due to the constant input of
sea-spray particles to the air and thus during rainshowers also to the
rainwater. The trace metal containing particles were dominated by Cr-containing
particles, which mainly seem to originate from the surface micro-layer of the
North Sea. The importance of the micro-layer as a source of trace metals was
confirmed during the analyses of the dissolved fraction, where a correlation was
found between high concentrations of trace metals and of marine compounds like
chlorine, sodium, sulphur and potassium in the dissolved fraction of the
collected rainwater.
Comparison of the suspended particles in rainwater and
aerosols collected above the North Sea and suspended particles collected in the
North Sea have revealed that the air is an important source for trace metal
containing and Ti-rich particles present in North Sea suspension. It also
revealed that the large quantities of Ca-containing particles present in the
North Sea suspension cannot originate from the air, and because only small
concentrations were reported to be present in riverine suspension, they have to
originate from marine production and from the erosion of the chalk cliffs of
Dover and Calais.
EPXMA has also been used to characterize suspension and
sediments from Lake Baikal and the Kara Sea, both located in Siberia. In Lake
Baikal, suspension samples have been collected at the inflow of the tributaries
and in the central part of the southern basin. The samples were dominated by
natural aluminosilicate and Si-rich particles, but traces of pollution were also
visible, especially in the southern basin. This pollution is not only produced
by the large pulp mill in Baikalsk, at the southern coast of the lake, but also
by the industry near Irkutsk and Ulan-Ude. In the northern basin, pollution was
visible at the Tiya River, which contained large abundances of Fe-rich particles
that most likely originate from debris dumping during the construction of the
Baikal-Amur railroad.
The influence of the Yenisey River on the composition
of the suspension and sediments of the Kara Sea was tested using suspension and
sediment samples collected from the estuary to 400 km in open sea. These samples
were dominated by aluminosilicate, Si-rich and Fe-rich particles. Some of these
Fe-rich particles also contained manganese and zinc and are thus most likely of
anthropogenic origin. The large amounts of Ti-rich particles present in these
samples are also though to have an important anthropogenic source. Only for the
Fe-containing aluminosilicates a decreasing trend was detected going from the
river to the open sea, which points to the Yenisey as the major contributor of
these particles. Due to the large numbers of overlapping particles (the filters
were heavily and inhomogeneously loaded) and the presences of crystallized
salts, especially sea salt (the filters were not rinsed with de-ionized water),
no extra information could be obtained about the trace particles and TSP of the
suspension samples. Although the information gained from these samples is
limited, the results are still presented, because these are the first results
ever to be published on the analyses of individual aquatic particles of a region
that is one of the main inputs of water to the Arctic.
In general it can be
stated that suspension and sediments present in lakes and seas are dominated by
natural materials originating from erosion and biogenic production, like
aluminosilicates and Si-rich particles, but the traces of anthropogenic inputs
are also visible, even in remote areas like Siberia.
Microanalysis of indoor and marine aerosols and cloud particles. LIEVE DE BOCK, 1998
This study reports on the micro-analytical characterisation of three different environmental particles: indoor aerosols, marine aerosols and cloud particles. Insight in the possibilities and applications of micro-beam techniques, in the field of single particle analysis, was acquired by a literature search of the period between January 1990 - January 1997. The conclusion of the review stated that micro-analysis on the single particle level has indeed been able to reveal unique information, inaccessible by bulk analysis. However, since each of those techniques has still its own drawbacks and no technique is capable of providing the complete characterisation of the sample, the combination of several complementary techniques to solve the problem is still required. Moreover there seems to exist a tendency towards particle analysis in the on-line configuration, in which particles are collected immediately into the instrument, eliminating typical problems associated with off-line techniques.
Multivariate techniques like cluster and factor analysis have become essential for the processing and interpretation of huge data sets, obtained by fully automated analytical techniques. The most important theoretical aspects of hierarchical cluster analysis (HCA) and principal factor analysis (PFA) were highlighted in this work. The combined approach of HCA and PFA, in the Integrated Data Analysis System (IDAS), for the processing of single North Sea aerosol data sets, appeared to be a remarkable technique to uncover the real intrinsic structure of the data set. The stability of the PFA procedure, as well as the reproducibility of the sampling campaign, was confirmed.
To elucidate the soiling of paintings in the Correr Museum in Venice, a combination of EPXMA, SEM-EDX, STEM-EDX, Nano-Probe, SPM and EDXRF was successfully applied for the complete characterisation of the individual indoor aerosol particles. Multivariate techniques performed on the EPXMA and SEM-EDX data revealed three aerosol sources and six to eight particle types. SEM-EDX and SPM mappings showed that the large number of elements present in particularly the Ca,Si-rich particles (diameters >8 mm), could be attributed to coagulation processes between Ca,Si-rich particles and a series of small particles. Nano-probe data of aerosol particles (diameters <100 nm) revealed that the in- and outdoor aerosol compositions were identical, in this size fraction. Information on the distribution and semi-quantification of trace elements inside the giant Ca,Si-rich aerosol particles was achieved by SPM measurements. A comparison between the in- and outdoor aerosol compositions suggested further the existence of an indoor Ca-rich aerosol source: probably the deterioration of wall plaster and building materials, and the strong accumulation of Ca-rich particles inside the museum. An evaluation of the composition of the particle size fraction, considered as potentially harmful for the paintings, revealed that sometimes almost all of these particles can be identified as a threat. Finally, the overall results clearly stressed the fact that the indoor air composition should be seen as a complex function of several factors. A controlled environment inside the museum will be necessary to avoid, on the one hand the infiltration of outdoor particles and, on the other hand the accumulation of particles in the museum. An adequate coating of the interior walls in the Correr Museum, to prevent particle production by deterioration of wall plaster and building materials, should be considered. Implementation of the suggested actions will finally lead to a better preservation of the visual qualities of the paintings in the Correr Museum in Venice.
Individual North Sea aerosol particles, sampled between 1993 and 1995, were studied by EPXMA and SEM-EDX in combination with multivariate techniques. Hierarchical cluster analysis revealed nine major particle types. All particle types were discussed in view of characteristic sampling periods which were classified, according to the air mass back-trajectories, in three categories: marine influenced periods, periods influenced by Scotland-England and by France. Air masses influenced by England seemed to contain important quantities of aluminosilicate particles and some Fe-rich particles, both enriched with S. The presence of gypsum particles on the other hand was more pronounced in air masses influenced by the south of England. Finally the main difference between the terrestrial influence of France and Scotland-England was encountered in the abundances of Fe-rich and gypsum particles. Additionally these French air masses were also characterized by a small number of heavy metal containing particles. Seasonal variations were investigated by comparing the composition of aerosol samples collected during the summer and the winter seasons. Air masses influenced by Scotland - E-England revealed higher abundances of aluminosilicate particles during the summer, whereas Pb-rich particles and Organic- and S-rich organic particles appeared to be more abundant during the winter season. The major difference between the summer and the winter marine air masses was found in the abundance of transformed sea salt particles. Finally, in a pure marine environment a higher organic particle abundance was found during the summer season. The identification of the particle origin was possible by performing principal factor analysis on the aerosol data of all five North Sea sampling campaigns. Two giant aerosol sources and three sub-micrometer particle sources were identified.
Despite the successful applications of FTIR in different fields, several problems were encountered in a case study concerning the FTIR-microscopic analysis of giant marine aerosol particles. In conclusion it appeared to be more interesting to combine EPXMA and FTIR for the analysis of particles with a higher concentration of organic material. In a second case study, the giant aerosol particle composition variations in air masses crossing the North Sea, were evaluated. After crossing a large distance above the North Sea, the abundance of marine crystallization products increased at the first two samples stages of the May impactor while the aluminosilicate abundance on the first three sample stages decreased. In some of the samples the transformed sea salt abundance decreased or even disappeared at higher stages in favour of pure NaCl. No significant decrease in particle diameter could be observed. The relation between the giant particle composition and their shape was obtained successfully by non-automated EPXMA. All particle shapes matched with those described in the literature, only for NaCl and CaSO4 unexpected shapes were detected.
To acquire a better understanding of the mechanisms responsible for the modification of marine stratocumulus clouds by emissions from ships, the composition of aerosols (>0.2 mm), collected during the MAST experiment, in different reservoirs (below-cloud ambient aerosol, ambient cloud droplet residual particles, ship plumes below-cloud, ship track cloud droplet residuals and above-cloud aerosol) was investigated by SEM-EDX. Conclusive evidence was found that combustion-derived particles emitted from a ship stack can result in cloud droplet formation in a ship track. The occurrence of Si-containing particles, in the below-cloud plume and ship track residual particle samples from a diesel-powered ship, provide the direct lick between aerosols emitted from the ship's stack to an effect in cloud. Additionally, it was found that a large fraction of the ambient aerosols were composed of organic material or organic material associated with chlorine. The number fraction of these organic or organohalogen particles was largest in clean marine boundary layers, and decreased with increasing pollution levels. The fraction of transformed sea salt increased with pollution level in the MBL, reflecting the increased anthropogenic impact in the more polluted boundary layers.
Evaluation and optimization of "Grazing Emission X-ray Fluorescence" spectrometry. MARTINE CLAES, 1999
Grazing-emission X-ray fluorescence (GEXRF) spectrometry is a recent XRF development based on the total reflection phenomenon using a wavelength-dispersive (WD) detection device. The idea and the technique are so new that only a prototype GEXRF-module exists at present and, at the start of this Ph. D.-work only, a few publications were available in literature.
The combination of grazing-emission XRF techniques with WD detection is based on the work of Becker et al., who stated in 1983 that XRF spectrometry can be made surface sensitive not only by grazing incidence of the exciting radiation, as in total reflection XRF (TXRF), but also by grazing emission of the characteristic radiation, i.e. by detecting only that part of fluorescence radiation that is emitted at grazing (otherwise known as "glancing") angles. The small solid angle of detection is compensated for by irradiating the sample directly with the uncollimated polychromatic radiation from the X-ray tube. Becker's results imply that GEXRF can be used for applications similar to those of (variable angle) TXRF, i.e. determination of the composition, thickness and density of thin layers and the analysis of elemental trace amounts on flat surfaces.
Two main advantages of GEXRF can be distinguished. First, the principal idea of GEXRF implies that the emitted characteristic radiation is only measured under an angle of a few minutes above the sample. Thus, the scattered radiation generated in the support material cannot be detected and the signal of a sample deposited on such a flat support can be measured in a background-free way, leading to extremely low detection limits (down to the sub-ppb level). Secondly, because of the WD detection, GEXRF also lends itself for the analysis of low-Z elements, which is an advantage over conventional TXRF.
Originally, the GEXRF unit was designed to be an accessory to a normal WD-XRF instrument, and it was expected to be especially powerful for ultratrace measurements, as are often required in environmental research projects. The aim of this work was to investigate how effective this system was in practical situations for the analysis of elemental trace amounts, to investigate ways in which the lower detection limits could be minimized and to optimize and evaluate the GEXRF technique for environmental sample analysis.
Grazing-emission XRF spectrometry utilizes WD-detection, as a result of which the range of elements accessible for grazing X-ray techniques is considerably extended towards the lighter elements. Because this softer characteristic radiation is more strongly absorbed in the matrix, it was of interest to investigate the extent of the linear response for micro- and trace analysis using GEXRF. This was done by calculating the fluorescence intensities as a function of layer thickness and composition, which is explained in more detail in Chapter II. The large path length of the emerged beam with photons of lower energy can cause matrix effects which could be harmful to the quantitative determination of elements. There are some conditions that have to be fulfilled to be able to apply the methods of quantification. The specimens are limited in thickness and consequently in area-related mass or covering of the carrier. Therefore, the critical thickness of a sample layer for which matrix effects can be considered as absent, was determined by studying the absorption-enhancement effects in thin sample layers for different analytes in three kinds of matrices, taking into account the interferences of the fluorescent radiation above the substrate.
The linear concentration range of GEXRF when applied to micro- and trace analysis was investigated. It was assumed throughout this study that in micro- and trace analysis the only reflecting optical interface present is that between the sample and the sample carrier. For an optimum signal-to-noise ratio in the measurement, the use of a sample carrier of higher mass density than the expected layer density is recommended. Linearity is ensured for ultra-thin (< 1 nm) layers, e.g. the sub-monolayer amounts encountered in silicon surface contamination analysis. For thicker layers, two effects cause non-linearity: oscillations in the calibration curve due to standing wave fields and negative deviations from linearity due to absorption of radiation by the matrix. The latter can be largely compensated for by the addition of an appropriate internal standard. Oscillations in the calibration curve are more complex. However, in real-life samples prepared by evaporation of aqueous droplets, oscillations in the calibration curve are likely to be less important. In preparing these samples, the exact morphology of the dried residue is not well controlled and generally a distribution of particulates of different sizes is deposited. Here, oscillations will be smoothed due to the averaging over the particle size distribution.
The possibility of using polycarbonate as an alternative to silicon and quartz glass as sample carrier in GEXRF has been investigated. The roughness and flatness were tested by means of a profilometer, from which it was concluded that polycarbonate suits as a cheaper alternative for silicon and quartz glass discs. Furthermore, a pretreatment of the carriers was applied to obtain an acceptable homogeneous distribution. Electron MicroProbe Analysis (EMPA) applications showed that this pretreatment leads to a better homogeneity of the sample deposit on the carrier. Sample preparation procedures for solid samples, aerosol samples and surface and thin layer samples are also investigated.
Further an attempt has been made to get a better idea about the analytical features of the grazing emission technique. While it is certainly true that no one technique can ever be expected to offer all of the features that a given analyst might desire, the GEXRF method has good overall performance characteristics. In contrast with a conventional TXRF set-up, all elements from Z > 4 (Be) can be determined in a WD-grazing emission mode if the instrument is equipped with suitable analyzing crystals. The good sensitivities for light elements allow the use of minute sample amounts for a non-destructive analysis. The improved peak-to-background ratio, due to geometrical optimizations, leads to correspondingly lower detection limits. Instrumental detection limits for chemical analysis within the range of 40 pg to 3 ng can be realized. This corresponds to a concentration of between 400 ng/l to 3 µg/l, if a sample volume of 100 µl is examined. The counting statistical error was calculated to be typically about 2 %. The accuracy is determined to some extent by matrix effects and by extraneous additions and losses before or during the measurement step. For the WD detection in the grazing emission technique, this accuracy is estimated to be better than 10%. Since the present GEXRF prototype is a sequential rather than a simultaneous instrument, the main disadvantage at the moment is the long analysis time when many elements have to be determined.
After the characteristic evaluation of the grazing emission device, the analytical performance of the technique is illuminated. The technique has been applied to various materials, among which water samples (dripping water, reference water standard, mineral water and seawater), biomaterials and pigment and aerosol samples. It should be pointed out that all these materials could successfully be analyzed with GEXRF. Only aerosol samples (because of geometrical problems) could not be analyzed in a stable way. In all other cases the reproducibility was about 10%. Given the prototype status of this grazing exit technique, the detection limits for light elements (sub-nanogram level) obtained for environmental sample analysis can be improved. However, for the high-Z elements, WD-GEXRF is expected not to be better than its related TXRF method.
The competitiveness of GEXRF is compared with efficient and well-established methods of X-ray fluorescence and other techniques for micro- and trace analysis. It is clear that there exists a wide variety of XRF techniques for trace analysis and that several techniques are quite competitive; in general, the choice of method to be used should be made for each case separately. The most important XRF-competitors of GEXRF are TXRF, synchrotron source spectrometers (SSXRF) and particle induced X-ray emission (PIXE). Two things that each of these special systems have in common are a very high sensitivity and ability to work with extremely low concentrations and/or small specimens. It is clear from the obtained results during this dissertation that the perspectives for trace analysis of liquid samples with GEXRF, as a macro-analytical tool, are not very promising since matrix effects are difficult to avoid. A second reason to pass GEXRF for trace analysis is the non-competitiveness of GEXRF or any other XRF technique with ICP-MS. However, if elemental traces in small volumes e.g. in biological tissues, have to be determined, the GEXRF technique has potential that ICP-MS does not have. Hence, this will be the application field for further optimization of the current GEXRF instrumental set-up.
The most promising features of GEXRF, however, are in the field of surface and thin-layer analysis. Trace contaminations on flat surfaces, like silicon wafers, can be determined and depth profiling can characterize stratified near-surface layers. The method is especially suitable for analysis of layers of nanometer thickness deposited on wafers.
Future developments to increase the sensitivity of GEXRF are situated in the field of synchrotron radiation. Designing a laboratory microprobe GEXRF spectrometer with simultaneous detection remains a great challenge. The application of synchrotron radiation to GEXRF analysis can inherently lead to better detection limits for low-Z elements in the fg region. However, the major problem of accessibility to such storage rings and experimental stations still persists.
Environmental analysis for conservation of museum objects and prehistoric cave paintings. KRISTIN GYSELS, 2000
This study is focussed on environmental analysis in view of conservation of our cultural and natural heritage. Two major issues of this work are concentrated on the preservation of museum objects on the one hand and prehistoric paintings in karstic caves on the other hand. A third topic deals with a field evaluation of aerosol sampling techniques for coarse particles. These play a major role in deposition processes and are thus very important in view of conservation of e.g. the North Sea environment.
In Chapter 1 of this dissertation, the environmental influence on preservation of museum objects and cave paintings is discussed. In the case of museums, several factors (micro-climate, gaseous, particulate and microbiological pollution) are important, of which only the influence of aerosols on the conservation of works of art is discussed extensively in this work. Chapter 1 starts with an overview of the sources, concentration and behaviour of indoor aerosols. The situation in museums is described more specifically. Soiling mechanisms and potentially harmful compounds are discussed as well. Principally, all atmospheric particles can be considered harmful because they can cause significant soiling when they are deposited onto the works of art. However, some compounds are more harmful because they can also cause chemical damage. From this point of view, especially S-rich, Fe-rich and organic particles are important.
Preservation of cave paintings is also discussed in Chapter 1. Aerosol pollution is less important in this case. The presence of visitors, releasing heat, water vapour and CO2 has a major influence. In this way, the natural cave environment, which has been built up over the centuries, is disturbed and the CaCO3/Ca(HCO3)2 equilibrium in the micrometric water film covering the paintings is disturbed. These mechanisms are discussed in more detail in Chapter 1. Control mechanisms caves can apply to minimise the effects of visitors are mentioned as well.
Chapter 2 gives an overview of the analytical techniques used in this work. For the analysis of the bulk aerosol concentrations, EDXRF and PIXE were applied. On a rather extensive amount of atmospheric and aquatic suspended matter samples, automated single particle analysis was performed with either SEM-EDX or EPMA. Dissolved compounds in the water samples were determined by IC, and ICP-AES or AAS. Soil samples were analysed by EDXRF, or EPMA and DRIFT. The main advantages and disadvantages of these techniques, in view of the types of samples analysed in this work, are discussed in Chapter 2.
The results of the characterisation of the indoor aerosol in four European museums are described in Chapter 3. The selection of these four museums was based on their architecture, climate and environment. The Correr Museum in Venice, Italy, the Sainsbury Centre for Visual Arts in Nowich, UK, the Kunsthistorisches Museum in Vienna, Austria and the Koninklijk Museum voor Schone Kunsten, Antwerpen, Belgium were chosen for a closer investigation. Bulk aerosol concentrations, as well as the composition of the individual particles, were determined. Comparison with the composition of the outdoor aerosol provided more information about the possible sources of the indoor particulate matter. Moreover, dry deposition samples were collected in order to determine what amount of particles could actually be deposited onto the works of art.
In the Correr Museum (CM) in Venice, degradation of wall plaster was found to be the major source of indoor particulate matter. This led to high concentrations of Ca-rich and Ca-Si particles. The influence of the outdoor atmosphere was not negligible either. Significant amounts of sea salt and S-rich particles were present in the indoor environment. No indoor sources were identified in the Sainsbury Centre for Visual Arts (SCVA) in Norwich. The outdoor air appeared to be the major source of indoor aerosols. Mainly S-rich particles were identified in winter, while in summer, sea salt particles were most abundant in the indoor air. The direct outdoor influence was minor in the Kunsthistorisches Museum (KHM) in Vienna. Construction works, carried out on the museum courtyard, generated many Ca-rich and Ca-Si particles, which ended up in the galleries through the air-conditioning system. In winter, a new elevator was constructed inside the museum, leading to even higher concentrations of these particle types. In the Koninklijk Museum voor Schone Kunsten (KMSK) in Antwerp, the outdoor influence was again larger. In winter, restoration and construction works constituted an additional indoor source of Ca-rich and Ca-Si particles. Along with sea salt, these were the main particle types identified in this season. In summer, S-rich particles were most abundant. The summer abundances of Ca-rich particles remained low, even though the museum is situated in a limestone building. Interior wall plaster and construction works apparently have a far greater influence on indoor Ca-concentrations.
In each museum, the influence of visitors was clearly reflected on the soil dust concentrations. Even though soil dust is a particle type of an outdoor origin, it was found to enter the museums in another way than other particles, which also have an outdoor source. Indoor relative abundances were usually higher than outdoors. Soil dust particles are most probably introduced by visitors and can later be resuspended. This process is even more efficient in the presence of a carpet. This hypothesis is supported by the clear influence of the number of visitors and the presence of carpets on the concentrations of soil-derived elements (Al, Si, Ti and Mn) in the four selected museums.
From the point of view of conservation, the situation was worst in the CM. Concentrations of potentially damaging S-rich and Fe-rich particles were higher than in the other museums. Moreover, significant soiling could be caused by the numerous Ca-rich and Ca-Si particles originating from degradation of wall plaster. In the SCVA and the KMSK, the works of art are not directly threatened by particulate pollution. Especially in the SCVA, they are adequately protected by display cases. Dry deposition values inside these cases were up to 100 times lower than out of the cases. In the KHM, soiling of the paintings could be induced by Ca-rich and Ca-Si particles originating from the construction works. Therefore, both in the CM and the KHM, the indoor air quality could be improved. However, it should be kept in mind that the construction works required to make the changes, could cause even more damage. This was clearly demonstrated by the results presented in Chapter 3. Leaving the situation as it is, even if not ideal, might cause less damage than the construction works needed to alter it.
Chapter 4 focuses on the analysis of aerosol, karstic water and soil samples from three European caves containing prehistoric rock art, namely the caves of Altamira and Tito Bustillo in Northern Spain and the Grotta dei Cervi in Southern Italy. In all three caves, the soil was found to the major factor determining the composition of both atmospheric and aquatic suspended particulate matter. In the Cave of Altamira, mainly calcite and aluminosilicate particles were identified. These particles were also present in the Tito Bustillo Cave, along with higher amounts of Si-rich particles. In this cave, the soil was also richer in Si than in Altamira. In the Grotta dei Cervi, significant amounts of P-containing biological particles were detected. These arise from the Guano (bat excrement) present in the cave in pure form, as well as mixed with the soil. In neither of the caves, any significant outdoor influence on the indoor aerosol was detected. Therefore, outdoor pollution does not constitute a serious threat for the paintings.
The composition of the karstic water was largely influenced by the sea. Relatively high Cl-concentrations were detected, which could have a negative influence on art conservation. At Tito Bustillo, this could even be enhanced by the high SO42- concentrations arising from discharge into the San Miguel River, which flows through the cave. No pigment particles were encountered in the dripping water samples collected underneath a painting, so direct erosion by the percolating water does not occur.
In combination with the results of the other research partners, it can be concluded that at Altamira visitors constitute the most serious threat to the preservation of the prehistoric paintings, in spite of the already rather strict visits regulation. At Tito Bustillo, biological colonisation, induced by the electrical lighting, is very important. Purification of the wastewater discharged into the San Miguel River is also required to improve the situation. No serious problems were detected in the Grotta dei Cervi, because the cave is still closed to the public. However, visitors could significantly increase the CO2 concentrations, and in combination with the high Cl-concentrations, this could constitute a problem when it is decided to turn the cave into a tourist attraction.
In Chapter 5, the results of a field evaluation of a wind tunnel-impactor system for sampling ambient aerosols are described. According to the theory of aerosol sampling, this system should be more efficient for the collection of coarse aerosol particles. On the average, when a Battelle impactor was operated inside a wind tunnel, in order to create isokinetic sampling conditions, higher apparent concentrations were found on the impactor stages with the largest cut-off values than on the corresponding stages of an identical impactor operating in the free wind. This is clearly indicated by the average elemental size distributions obtained by means of these two sampling techniques.
When individual samples were evaluated as a function of the weather conditions, the obtained results were mostly in agreement with theoretical considerations. In calm air conditions, higher concentrations were detected on the largest stages of the impactor operated in the wind tunnel, as well as for sampling periods when the wind came from the Southwest, aligned with the anisokinetic impactor. No significant differences between the two employed sampling methods could be detected when heavy rainfall occurred, possibly due to a more efficient removal of large particles by washout and rainout processes. When the wind directions were highly variable and when wind blasts occurred, inaccurate sampling also took place in the wind tunnel, probably because of the inefficiency of the wind tunnel system in these extreme conditions. For three out of 24 samples, no explanation for the observed results could be found based on the above-described considerations. Other effects, or a combination of these, like turbulence or secondary aspiration, could be responsible.
It can be concluded that operating a sampling device in a wind tunnel is useful when the weather conditions are not too extreme. In comparison with an impactor operated in the free wind, relative concentration differences of 20 to 150 % can occur. Generally, these differences are higher for the largest particles (> 4 µm dae), so especially when this particle size range is to be studied, the use of a wind tunnel can be recommended. When aerosol size distributions are assessed by means of cascade impactors, a significant underestimation of this size fraction can occur when the impactor is operated in the free wind.
Aerosol science nowadays takes an
important place in environmental analysis. This is due to the fact that aerosol
particles play an essential role in air pollution, climate change and public
health. Despite this, there still exists a lot of uncertainty in this field so
that a further chemical and physical characterisation of atmospheric aerosols is
needed. The work presented here summarises the results of several case studies,
which were carried out in the framework of a number of national and
international projects, in order to expand our knowledge about aerosols and to
reduce the uncertainties.
In Chapter 1 of this
work, an overview is given of the different characteristics of atmospheric
aerosol particles. After defining atmospheric aerosols, the different ways of
classifying them is discussed. Aerosols are produced as primary or secondary
particles from both natural and anthropogenic sources. Once the particles have
been emitted into or formed in the air, they can undergo a variety of
transformation processes, including condensation and coagulation. The cycle ends
by the processes by which they are being removed from the atmosphere. Dry
removal processes include impaction, sedimentation and diffusion; wet removal
processes can be divided into rainout and washout. These processes, together
with physical properties, like particle size, determine the residence time of
the particles in the air. The last section of Chapter 1 deals with the
different effects of atmospheric aerosols. Their influence on public health,
visibility, acid rain and a number of effects due to particle deposition is
being summarised. More recently the possible climatic effects of aerosol
particles have been recognised. Aerosol particles influence the global climate
both by scattering radiation and by influencing cloud properties.
Chapters 2 and 3 summarise the
results of two case studies on North Sea aerosols. Chapter 2 focuses
on Ca-containing particles, especially CaSO4 for five different
(wind)sectors that could be identified. EPXMA data of about 50,000 individual
aerosol particles were subjected to non-hierarchical cluster analysis, revealing
that Ca-containing particles are present in all sectors mainly under the form of
CaSO4 and aluminosilicates, in variable amounts. Marine air masses
are characterised by rather low fractions of Ca-enriched particles. On the other
hand extremely high fractions are present for the continental air masses and
more particularly those coming from the central and northern part of Germany.
The big difference between the northern and southern continental air masses
suggests some important anthropogenic sources in the former region. Similar
trends are found for the CaSO4 fractions. In most cases CaSO4
particles are the main cause of the occurrence of Ca-containing particles.
Marine and continental sources of gypsum are identified, the former being only
of minor importance. The cluster analysis of the Ca-enriched particles yields
several particle types. CaSO4, with abundances of more than 30%, is
by far the most important one. Other groups present are the aluminosilicates and
CaCO3. Minor particle types include Fe-Ca-rich and Ca-S-Si-rich
particles. The combination of Ca-enriched particles with sea salt particles is
probably due to a marine origin or coagulation of particles. The sources for
each of the identified types are discussed in more detail.
In Chapter 3
literature data on Cd, Cu, Pb, Zn, Ni and Cr concentrations in aerosols above
the North Sea have been gathered and intercompared to look for possible trends.
A distinction is made between measurements in different regions of the North
Sea. Also the sources and magnitude of the emissions are discussed.
The majority of the data on trace
metals in the literature deals with the Southern Bight. So the trends observed
for this part of the North Sea are the most reliable. In this part of the North
Sea also the highest concentrations are found. More data are needed to confirm
the concentration patterns found for the other regions.
Despite some heavy fluctuations a
strong decreasing trend is observed for the Pb and Zn concentrations above the
North Sea. A remarkably consistent correlation is found between the
concentration patterns of both elements in most parts of the North Sea. This
similar behaviour between Pb and Zn is most clearly seen for the Southern Bight.
Only in the coastal area of the central North Sea a different behaviour is
found. Here Zn concentrations are increasing and Pb and Zn are anti-correlated.
For Cd, Cu, Ni and Cr, much less
data are available in the literature. Despite this, also for Cd a decreasing
trend is present, however not as strong as for Pb and Zn. The airborne Cu levels
above the different regions of the North Sea do not always show a consistent
behaviour. In most cases, however, the levels found in the late eighties and
early nineties are lower than those observed earlier. Cr and Ni concentrations
in most cases are fluctuating, without a certain pattern so with the small
amount of data it is hard to recognise a particular trend.
In Chapter 4 a new
approach is described to apply EPXMA for the estimation of the homogeneity of
powder samples of candidate reference materials (RM), basing on the utilisation
of the Kolmogorov-Smirnov statistics. The procedure was applied in the study of
the “within-bottle” homogeneity of three candidate reference materials and
the “bottle-to-bottle” homogeneity of a fourth reference material.
In the within-bottle homogeneity
study, the distribution of the particle size and concentration of the main
elements are the same for two of the three RMs so that they can be used as
standards for microanalysis for amounts down to the nanogram. The third sample
was found to be inhomogeneous at that level regarding its chemical composition.
In the bottle-to-bottle
homogeneity study, all bottles of the candidate RM, except one, were found to be
homogeneous at the level of ca. 300 ng. One out of the remaining five
bottles becomes different from the other four samples, when the sample mass is
being reduced down to 8 ng.
Even though the number of
particles analysed using CC EPXMA is very small compared to that collected, the
major elements for the studied candidate RM need to be analysed just for less
than 200 particles, to assure 5% RSD in CC EPXMA measurements. For the minor
elements, the required number of particles to be analysed, to assure 5% RSD,
ranges from several thousands to tens of thousands. The number of particles
required to be analysed, to insure a certain level of reproducibility, increases
exponentially as the concentration of elements decreases.
Chapters 5 and 6 both focus on
atmospheric aerosols, collected in the Former Soviet Union. In Chapter 5,
the results are summarised of two sampling campaigns at a high mountain station
in Kazakhstan. The background character of the site was confirmed by comparing
the elemental concentrations, obtained by EDXRF analysis, with those reported
for other remote stations. Based on the variability of the elemental
concentrations, the elements could be classified into two groups: highly
variable Si, Al, Fe, K, Ca, Ti, Sr and Mn concentrations and less variable S,
Pb, Zn, Cl, Br, Cr, Ni and Cu concentrations. The latter indicates distant
sources and mixing of the aerosol before reaching the sampling site. The
concentrations of the first group of elements were found to be highly
correlated, suggesting that they are originating from the same sources. These
findings, complemented with enrichment factor calculations revealed the first
group of elements to be originating mainly from more local sources (soil dust),
and the second group to be related to long-range transport of anthropogenic
aerosol.
Automated single particle
analysis by SEM-EDX and subsequent cluster analysis resulted in the
identification of 12 distinct aerosol particle types. Relative particle type
abundances were converted to absolute abundances by estimating the number
concentrations for the detected particles. A very pronounced seasonal variation
of the particle number concentration is found, especially in springtime due to
the melting of the snow cover.
The seasonal variation of the
abundance of the different particle types was investigated. From the relative
abundances only limited information could be extracted. Based on the absolute
abundances, a strong seasonal pattern is found for Si-Al-Fe-rich, Si-rich,
Ca-S-Si-rich, Ca-Si-rich, Fe-Si-rich and Ti-Si-rich particles, closely related
to the particle number concentration. These particle types can mainly be
attributed to local soil dust. The existence of some additional, but weaker
sources is suggested by small differences in the summer patterns. For most of
the remaining particle types a completely different seasonal trend is found.
They are composed of elements like Pb, Zn and S, which can be related to
anthropogenic emissions. Their abundance in winter can be completely attributed
to long-range transport of anthropogenic aerosols. In summer, emissions from the
Almaty region are superimposed on this base level. An annual cycle can be seen
for biogenic aerosols, produced by natural sources, reaching their maximum
activity in August.
In Chapter 6, the
case of several anthropogenically influenced sites in the FSU is being
investigated, with main focus on a sampling campaign near the city of
Krasnoyarsk. Next to the bulk results by EDXRF and SEM-EDX results, a literature
study is presented on the industrial activities in the different regions of the
Siberian territory.
All bulk elemental concentrations
at the Krasnoyarsk site were found to be higher than those at the Tien Shan
background station. Studying the time evolution of the Krasnoyarsk bulk
concentrations, air masses of different origin can be observed. Clean conditions
are characterised by concentrations less than 2.6 times the Tien Shan background
values, close to the global rural average. During polluted periods ratios up to
50 are observed, but still lower than the global urban average. Enrichment
factor calculations indicated that almost all elements are enriched compared to
the soil.
The application of
non-hierarchical cluster analysis on the overall data set, obtained by SEM-EDX,
resulted in the identification of 10 distinct aerosol particle types in the
Krasnoyarsk winter aerosol. Relative particle abundances were converted into
absolute abundances by estimating the particle number concentration, which was
found to be about 20 times higher than the average winter background value at
the Tien Shan site. The increase in the bulk concentrations during the sampling
was confirmed by an increase in the particle number concentration.
For the source identification of
the different particle types, the time evolution of their absolute abundances
was investigated. Based on these results, four groups of particle types were
found with similar time profiles. According to the Al profile, which can be
directly linked to the aluminium industry in Krasnoyarsk, the second half of the
sampling period was found to be strongly influenced by emissions from the city
of Krasnoyarsk and its industrial activities. The Krasnoyarsk industrial area
aerosol was also characterised by high amounts of Ca-S-rich, S-rich, low-Z and
Fe-S-(Si)-rich particles, for which several sources could be identified in the
city and its surroundings.
During the first part of the
sampling campaign, the city’s influence was non-existent. On the base level,
representing the Siberian background, two other pollution episodes are
superimposed. A first episode, characterised by high abundances of Pb and
Pb-Zn-rich particles is thought of originating from mining activities, north of
the sampling site. Several coal combustion products could also be detected.
Another pollution episode could be attributed to the emissions of wood burning
for domestic heating in some smaller settlements free from industrial
activities. For the conclusions regarding the other regions we would like to
refer to Chapter 6.
In the framework of the Second
Aerosol Characterisation Experiment, described in Chapter 7, size
segregated samples have been collected for single particle analysis on the
island of Tenerife, in both the marine boundary layer (MBL) and the free
troposphere (FT). They were analysed by automated and manual SEM-EDX, followed
by cluster analysis to identify the different particle types present in the
aerosol and their abundance.
Basing on backtrajectory
calculations and particle number and volume concentrations, different periods
can be identified regarding the origin of the sampled air masses. In the FT, the
air masses can be classified as clean Atlantic or influenced by dust from Africa
or pollution from Europe. A specific situation occurred, which could only be
identified by local observations when the cloud layer was just below the
sampling site. In the MBL, air masses are classified as clean or polluted by
European emissions, basing on the trajectories, and an additional class of
perturbed samples (aged pollution), taking into account the aerosol volume
concentration.
For the FT samples a very good
agreement was found between the chemical composition of the samples and the air
mass type, which was confirmed by applying principal component analysis.
Variations of the chemical composition within a particular air mass type are
only of minor importance compared to the differences between the air mass types.
A fairly good agreement is observed also for the MBL samples but this needed
some more consideration.
For both the FT and MBL samples,
the biggest change in chemical composition is observed between the fine and
coarse mode aerosol. The FT fine mode aerosol is dominated by S-poor
aluminosilicates in the case of the dust samples or sulphates, carbonaceous
particles and S-rich aluminosilicates in the polluted samples. The clean samples
(and the ones taken in cloudy conditions) have an intermediate composition. When
going to the larger size fractions, a strong decreasing trend is observed for
the sulphates and carbonaceous particles. On the other hand, the S-poor
aluminosilicates (and especially their ratio to the S-rich (or aged)
aluminosilicates) and the Ca-rich particles are becoming relatively more
important.
The MBL fine mode aerosol is completely dominated by sulphates, and to a lesser extent, carbonaceous particles and aged sea salt, in the case of polluted and perturbed air masses. No fresh sea salt particles are found in the fine aerosol for these air masses. The clean air masses, in their fine mode, are made up mainly of sea salt particles with varying degrees of ageing. A drastic change in chemical composition is observed between the fine and coarse mode aerosol. When going to the larger size fractions, the latter is more and more dominated by fresh sea salt particles. Also the difference between the air mass types is largely reduced.
Morphological, microstructural and chemical characterisation of individual soot aggregates from different sources by electron microscopical techniques. AN SMEKENS, 2000
The increase of fine aerosol in the environment has been a hot topic in the last years. Particles with small diameters can penetrate deeply into the airways and thus cause a lot of harmful health effects. Soot, a major component of fine atmospherical dust, is one of the least understood atmospheric aerosols. Incomplete combustion forms particles, which condense into a black aerosol when cooling down. Due to their small dimensions (10 nm to 2 µm), their structure, and the ability to adsorb thousands of different species, these particles can cause severe health effects to men. Because soot scatters and absorbs light strongly and because it enhances cloud formation, it plays an important role in global change. These effects are enforced by the long residence times in the atmosphere and by the transport over long distances.
Because of the effects soot causes, the morphology, microstructure and chemical composition are studied to understand how these effects are produced and how they could be avoided. Since these characteristics of the soot depend on the formation conditions and on the combustion process, some are different for soot of different sources. Thus, it might be possible to designate the origin of environmental soot particles.
Environmental soot principally originates from the combustion of fossil fuel. The main source of soot in the atmosphere is diesel traffic. Other important sources are heating, air traffic and industry. Therefore, we focus in this study on soot emitted by a car, running on diesel and biodiesel, both at idle run and at stationary regime, soot from a oil-fired domestic heating installation and soot from an aircraft exhaust. Carbon black, a product with similar features as soot, used commercially, is used as a kind of reference material.
By performing individual particle analysis, both the morphology and the composition are measured on single particles. The main advantage over bulk analysis is that we gain more detailed information on the nature of the particles, their origin, their formation processes and their potential transformation in the environment. In order to link these parameters up, the particles are in this work characterised as a function of their aerodynamic diameter. The aerodynamic diameter is an important physical dimension in describing aerosols when considering diffusional or inertial deposition into the human respiratory system and when considering particle transport and deposition in the atmosphere. A methodology was established to characterise the morphology of aggregates with automated image analysis on transmission electron microscopical (TEM) photographs. The newly defined parameters that describe the morphology indicate differences for soot of different origin.
Studying the electronic bonding state of carbon, the main constituent of soot, we see that the soot from domestic heating, diesel soot and carbon black all have a significant amount of double bonding character. The analysis of the elemental composition, by energy dispersive X-ray analysis (TEM-EDX), shows that carbon, oxygen and sulphur, probably in the form of adsorbed sulphate, are present in all soot types. The chemical composition differs for different sources.
The size distributions of the soot aggregates, studied by image analysis of field emission scanning electron microscopical (FE-SEM) images, show that the majority occurs in the smallest fraction of the studied range (0.15-0.45 µm). This trend is most pronounced for aircraft exhaust soot, with almost 80 % of the particles having a size of 0.15 µm.
Next to these results, also the visual interpretation of high resolution TEM (HRTEM) images enables to differentiate between soot emitted by different sources, which can make it possible to determine the origin of soot in the environment.
The marine environment and weathering of historic stone monuments. FILIP DELALIEUX, 2001
Sculptures and monuments are often made of porous materials that are subject to the singular or combined action of different weathering phenomena: e.g. dissolution (intensified by air pollutants), freeze/thaw and wet/dry cycles, salt crystallisation and biological attack. Salt weathering of building stones is recognised as one of the primary agents in the loss of historic architecture. The growth of salt crystals within the stone pores can generate stresses that are sufficient to overcome the stone's tensile strength and disintegrate the stone into a powder or flakes. Salt accumulations found in historic buildings originate from a variety of sources, e.g. air pollution, rising groundwater, marine spray, unsuitable cleaning material, incompatible building materials, microbiological activity and de-icing salts. In the past most research has been focused on the salt input caused by air pollution, mainly through deposition of SO2 and sulphuric acid and the subsequent enrichment with sulphates. In recent decades the atmospheric SO2-concentrations have declined markedly in developed countries and the lack of knowledge on natural salt input sources such as microbiological colonisation and sea-salt have become more apparent.
The research presented here is concerned with the latter source of soluble salts and the effects of marine salts on various types of natural building stones (e.g. granites, limestone and sandstone). In the context of a project funded by the EC, stone monuments located in four different coastal environments were studied. In addition to the in-situ exposed stone blocks, analyses were also performed on small stone prisms, which were freshly quarried and submitted to artificially accelerated weathering (allowing the simulation of stone deterioration in a coastal environment on a practicable time scale and under standardised conditions). Soluble salt concentrations were determined with Ion Chromatography (IC) and Inductively Coupled Plasma-Atomic Emission Spectroscopy (ICP-AES). Micrometer-scale salt distributions inside the stone samples were investigated with a Scanning Electron Microscope equipped with an Energy Dispersive X-ray detection system (SEM-EDX). To get a detailed view on the range of marine salts over land, atmospheric deposition was collected as a function of distance from the coastline and altitude, and analysed with IC and ICP-AES. To get a broader view on the distribution of the deposition of marine salts over land, rain chemistry data from European monitoring stations were compiled and Cl- and Na+ - concentrations were mapped using kriging interpolation. The described research has shown roughly how much and at what depth NaCl is expected to crystallise in different stone types. It was also shown that the NaCl-content is not directly proportional to the susceptibility of the stone type to sea-salt decay. This susceptibility is mainly determined by the pore network characteristics.
The amounts of NaCl deposited from the atmosphere and accumulated in monument stones decrease logarithmically and are linearly interrelated. The influence of microclimatic conditions at the stone surface (e.g. airflow and sun exposure) on the NaCl-concentrations in the stone were found to be up to the same order of magnitude as the influence of the distance to the coastline.
The new insights and quantitative results obtained in this study improve the assessment of the susceptibility of natural stone to sea-salt decay. They help to design more efficient conservation strategies, especially for the numerous monuments located in coastal areas. More generally, this work provides the possibility to predict the order of magnitude of the amount of sea-salt to which an outdoor construction is exposed. Studying the problem of sea-salt decay has not only solved answers but has raised additional questions by exposing shortcomings in the theories and instrumental methods used in this field. We were able to clearly pinpoint these shortcomings and have outlined new pathways for future research.
Atmospheric deposition of nutrients to aquatic ecosystems. KURT EYCKMANS, 2003
Man’s activities, which introduce an excess of nutrients, along with other pollutants, into lakes, streams, estuaries and seas, are causing significant changes in aquatic environments. The pollution problem is critical, because of increased population, industrial growth, intensification of agricultural production, river-basin development, recreational use of waters, and domestic and industrial exploitation of shore properties. Accelerated eutrophication causes changes in plant and animal life, changes that often interfere with the use of water and that reduce property values.
The influence of the atmosphere as a transport route of nutrients to aquatic ecosystems such as the North Sea and lake Balaton (Hungary) has been studied in detail. The atmospheric deposition depends totally on the emission sources and various removal mechanisms. The atmospheric deposition of nutrients is, however, not easily measured. For the wet deposition, practical implications, such as sea or lake water spray, makes the amount of precipitation hard to determine. Dry deposition is even more difficult to measure and it is not possible to do so routinely. Because of these reasons, it is not easy to estimate the nutrient input to the water surface from measurements and, therefore, atmospheric transport models are frequently used. In these models, all the processes influencing the concentrations of all the involved components are taken into account from the place where the sample is originally taken to the place where the deposition finally occurs.
For the North Sea (see Chapter III), nutrients are defined by the OSPAR convention (the Convention for the Protection of the Marine Environment of the North-East Atlantic) as one of the most important human pressures. The excessive anthropogenic input of nutrients from land and changed nutrient ratios primarily affect the coastal zone. Most of the nutrient related problems occur in particular in estuaries and fjords, or in parts of the North Sea where the riverine input is poorly mixed with fresh marine water. These negative impacts include periodic disturbances of the ecosystem, as well as changes in the abundance and diversity of different faunal and floral communities. Data from a sampling campaign of nearly one year at the Belgian coast were used to optimise the model’s parameters in order to obtain a more accurate calculation of the deposition of the various nutrients above the North Sea.
For Lake Balaton (chapter IV), much research has been carried out concerning the eutrophic episodes. However, limited research has been done about the atmospheric input of various nutrients. This less trivial nutrient input source could lead to an underestimation of the total nutrient budget and should not be neglected. Especially in regions far downstream the river Zala such as the Siofok basin and during periods when there is a strong nitrogen limitation or depletion, the atmosphere could be the most important source of nutrient compounds to the water. Many scientists already stated that the atmosphere is a very important source of nitrogen compounds, with special attention to ammonia. Previous studies managed to make some accurate flux calculations of ammonia to the lake, taking into account the specific lake conditions. However, these studies were carried out in the beginning of the 1980s and since then, the lake’s water composition as well as the atmospheric composition drastically changed. In this study, the contribution of the atmosphere as a source of gaseous and particulate nutrients was investigated and the importance of this contribution evaluated for the whole lake.
Furthermore, the complementary information in combining two analytical techniques, bulk Ion Chromatography and Thin Window Electron Probe Micro Analysis, is demonstrated (Chapter V). Combining the results of both techniques, we have been able to make a more detailed interpretation of the aerosols in the air mass.
Finally, in Chapter VI, the different outputs of various ammonia samplers, both active as passive, have been compared. The systems were evaluated concerning their precision, reliability and labour intensity. This study resulted in a profound validation of the working of the lab’s ammonia sampler and possible explanations for deviating results were formulated.
Optimisation and application of different Electron Probe X-ray Microanalysis approaches for the chemical characterisation of individual environmental particles. ANNA DE MAEYER-WOROBIEC, 2004
The study of atmospheric aerosols has recently become very important for two major reasons: the small particle size fraction has a very important influence on human health, and it affects the global climate. Characterization of individual microscopic particles generally permits more information to be obtained than is feasible with bulk analysis. As a result recognition of pollution sources and processes becomes simplified and facilitated. The characterisation of single environmental particles using micro-analytical techniques plays an important role in the environmental science.
In the framework of this Ph.D., particular attention was paid to the application of EPMA to the analysis of single environmental particles. Apart from detailed information on chemical composition and size distribution, another important advantage is the possibility of automation that allows large numbers of particles to be analysed for a better statistical result. On the other hand, the development of thin-window energy-dispersive detectors was of major importance for electron probe microanalysis (EPMA), in order to detect light elements (6<Z). Using the thin-window EPMA, the diversity and the complex heterogeneity of the chemical composition of atmospheric particles can be investigated. In the framework of this investigation a short survey of the possibilities as well as the applications of quantitative EPMA is given. Unlike conventional EPMA, the recent thin-window technique combined with the quantification based on the Monte Carlo simulations allows the concentration of low-Z elements such as carbon, nitrogen and oxygen to be determined.
Apart from the thin-window EPMA approaches, there are also other alternative EPMA methods. For samples containing large numbers of biogenic and organic particles impregnation with heavy metals can be used. The “spot-test“ or microchemical transformation is another analytical procedure based on micro-chemical reactions. Their use in optical microscopy is described, while their application to common atmospheric aerosol anions such as sulphate, chloride or nitrate is also addressed.
Using
thin-window EPMA, the low–Z element information is obtained to better account for the overall chemical composition. In this way the classification
of individual particles can be at least semi-quantitatively assessed. However,
one of the most important problems of EPMA remains beam damage, which causes
geometrical and morphological structures to be changed during analysis. These
artefacts cannot be accounted for in quantitative concentration calculations. It
should also be noted that knowledge about the particle concentrations plays a
very significant role in the study of environmental pollution. The use of a
liquid-nitrogen-cooled sample stage during the automated analysis of the
atmospheric aerosol particles results in a spectacular protection against the
beam damage effect. It seems that the beam damage depends not only on the
composition of the particles, but also the diameter of the particles and their
shape. Moreover, the collection substrate for atmospheric particles plays an
important role during the beam damage process.
In the framework of these Ph.D. investigations, some examples of the application of quantitative thin-window EPMA in environmental research are presented. The results from the analysis of the individual atmospheric particles collected in the Amazon Basin, South Africa and Balaton Lake in Hungary are discussed in detail. Since the development and the optimisation of this new method are still in progress, the interpretation of the results and quantification should be done with caution. The comparison of the quantitative results from thin-window EPMA with those obtained from the conventional EPMA is also presented in detail.
Optimization and environmental application of TW-EPMA for single particle analysis. JOHAN DE HOOG, 2005
The
thesis describes the different steps that were taken for developing a new method
for the semi-quantitative analysis and characterization of (environmental)
particles by TW-EPMA.
First,
we evaluated the need for such a new method by showing the different
technological evolutions in electron microscopy. We saw that with the arrival of
a new generation of energy-dispersive X-ray detectors, it became possible to
determine light elements. Their ultra-thin polymer windows allow for a better
transmission of low-energy X-rays, which made sure that at least qualitative
analysis of elements with an atomic number Z > 5 was possible. Since these
light-element compounds are very abundant in environmental particles, the
breakthrough in detector technology was also a big step forward for enhancing
our knowledge about their composition. The use of a so-called cold stage for
cooling down samples with liquid nitrogen to –193 °C also allowed us to
analyze volatile species, for example ammonium and nitrate compounds, since we
could considerably reduce the beam damage effects.
Soon
the idea rose to investigate the possibility to develop a method for the
quantification of both light and heavy elements contained in environmental
particles. A recently developed Monte Carlo model for the simulation of
electron-solid interactions at low energies was adapted for particulate samples
by implementing the necessary features for taking into account particle geometry
effects. The Monte Carlo model was integrated into an algorithm for the
iterative quantification of particle compositions based on reverse simulations.
While testing the quantification method using particle standards made of
inorganic and organic salts, several directly or indirectly critical aspects
were investigated in order to adapt the involved analytical procedures like the
sample preparation (the quality of substrates and the use of coatings), the beam
damage effects, the spectrum evaluation (peak identification and corrections for
peak overlap) and the physical parameters used in the model. A comparison with
other quantification methods showed that our method produced quite satisfying
results, also considering the uncertainties and assumptions we had to deal with.
Then,
we tried to go one step further by exploring several possibilities to get the
most out of the obtained concentrations for light and heavier elements. For the
characterization of environmental samples, huge datasets have to be dealt with
in a fast, efficient and intelligent way to get a correct profile of the
analyzed particles. Experiments with artificial particles showed that the
calculation of light element concentrations by our iterative Monte Carlo
quantification procedure indeed produced an added value for differentiating
between different particle types when applying data reduction tools. These
mathematical methods are able to reduce large datasets to smaller sets of
specific characteristic parameters. The purely mathematical data treatment was
then extended with an expert system for the elucidation of particle composition.
The mental algorithms used to identify particle types were translated into an
automatic procedure that could do the same job of the analyst in an unsupervised
and computerized way. This method starts on the individual particle level and
ends with the classification of similar particles into typical groups.
Two methods were developed and
tested for the additional characterization of the internal particle composition.
Grazing-Exit EPMA (GE-EPMA) could offer specific information about core-shell
structured particles, but some disadvantages due to beam damage and the
instrumental setup strongly limited the possibilities and made data
interpretation quite difficult. Multiple-Voltage EPMA (MV-EPMA) appeared
to have more potential, since particles are analyzed at different voltages to
vary the information depth, so that layered particles could be qualitatively
differentiated from homogeneous particles. The technique was also used to
determine the surface layer thickness of artificial, heterogeneous particles,
but beam damage again played a disadvantageous role. It is clear that the
application of GE-EPMA or MV-EPMA to real atmospheric particles will probably be
limited to qualitative analysis due to the complexity involved in the analysis,
since both their complex chemical composition and their structural heterogeneity
cannot be known a priori. It was however shown that both techniques, in
combination with light-element analysis, are able to extract information that
could not be obtained before.
The developed and optimized
method was also put into use by applying it in projects that required the
characterization of different environmental samples. The semi-quantitative
determination of light elements by TW-EPMA was applied to the analysis of North
Sea aerosol particles, and it showed to be an efficient tool for the
investigation of a huge number of individual microparticles. The method offered
good statistics to study their chemical properties and their behavior in the
atmosphere. The results of the collected aerosol samples showed that the
light-element analysis of single particles gave additional useful chemical
information to marine aerosol studies, compared to the conventional EPMA
methods. The detection of characteristic X-ray radiation of low-Z elements,
which was not possible before, offered the possibility to identify more
compounds (e.g. NH4NO3, organic particles), or it enabled
the differentiation between particle types, like e.g. (NH4)2SO4
and sulphur-containing organic particles which previously only showed a sulphur
peak in their X-ray spectra. The extended, semi-quantitative knowledge of low-Z
element concentrations led to a more relevant particle classification;
therefore, the possible sources and interactions occurring in the troposphere
can be traced in much more detail by the analysis of large numbers of individual
particles. Through the combination of chemical data with meteorological data,
the environmental link was found between the chemical composition of the
different samples and the environmental conditions during sampling.
TW-EPMA has already been
applied in many projects for the characterization of different sample types from
around the world, like atmospheric aerosols (Amazon region, Brazil; Lake
Balaton, Hungary; North Sea; sugar cane plantation, Brazil; indoor and outdoor
environments in residential areas, Flanders; indoor and outdoor environments
near historical monuments all over Europe) and sediment particles (North Sea;
Tisza river, Hungary). For this thesis, the method was compared to and combined
with different complementary bulk techniques. As well in the abovementioned
North Sea project, as in another project for the characterization of PM2.5
in Flanders, it was shown that TW-EPMA could offer new insights in the
composition and (trans)formation of particulate matter in the atmosphere. The
combination with ion chromatography showed that the matching of bulk and
microanalytical results could lead to mutual benefits in aerosol
characterization. TW-EPMA proved to be a valuable element in the
multi-analytical approach of the PM2.5 study in Flanders.
Should the method from now on be used in every project about the characterization of environmental particles? No, because for some problems a qualitative approach is already enough or the knowledge about light elements is not necessary. For example, studies about the distribution of heavy metals in river sediments will probably not always require an exhaustive and time-consuming quantitative characterization of the light-element composition. The analyst will have to evaluate what is the scope of the projects and what are the capabilities of the available methods in order to choose the right level of characterization. TW-EPMA combined with our quantification method has proven to be a valuable tool for single particle analysis, with still some considerable potential for improvements in the future … when better technology will again lead to new insights.
Characterisation of health related particulate and gas-phase compounds in multiple indoor and outdoor sites in Flanders. MARIANNE STRANGER, 2005
The quality of the air we breathe has been studied and evaluated extensively worldwide, not only because of its known harmful effects on the climate, vegetation and our cultural heritage, but also because of its recognized potential to cause adverse health effects on human kind. This work aimed to assess the results of a pilot study on the characterisation of gas-phase and particulate matter air pollutant levels in Flanders in different environmental settings, with special reference to its applicability as indicators for the personal exposure of the population.
The
majority of the available open literature concerning the causal relationship
between air pollution and the morbidity and mortality rates of a population,
focussed on the hypothesis that ambient levels of air pollution, measured at one
or a few fixed ambient air monitoring sites, could be related to the health
implications of a broader population. Furthermore, these studies hypothesised
that each individual of a population has a similar personal exposure to air
pollution, which is directly related to the ambient pollutant levels measured at
one ambient monitoring site. Besides climatological and vegetative arguments,
these studies have lead to the establishment of a legislation which is fixed to
the control and -if necessary- the reduction of outdoor air pollution. To test
the hypothesis that the air quality information obtained from a fixed regional
sampling station is an estimation of the quality of air the larger population is
exposed to, the obtained data were evaluated against those of a fixed monitor.
In
order to assess the situation of the outdoor air pollution in Flanders, this
work presented four case-studies which aimed to characterise the outdoor air
quality at specific critical sites. Two programs focused on the gas-phase
pollutants and two others on the particulate matter phase. For the gaseous
pollutants, the attention was paid to two areas in Flanders: in the first case
study the ambient levels of the precursor gases NO2, SO2
and O3 were assessed in the city centre of Antwerp and the southern
suburbs Wilrijk and Hoboken. On a larger scale, the second case study focused on
the ambient NO2 levels in West-Flanders. Not only was the seasonal
variability of these pollutants studied, but also the concentration differences
due to local (traffic-)emissions. The traffic related pollutant NO2
occurred at considerably higher concentrations in the urban centres compared to
the more rural suburbs, whereas the ambient O3 levels occurred
inversely correlated to ambient NO2. So-called hotspot sites in both
areas were characterised by the most elevated NO2 levels and the
corresponding lowest O3 levels. The results pointed out that the
existing interpolation charts for NO2 based on fixed sampling site
measurements underestimated the ambient levels at certain sites in West-Flanders.
In general, the ambient NO2 levels increased at increasing distance
from the North Sea. In Antwerp, SO2, which is independent of traffic
emissions, occurred at higher levels in the southern suburbs; the nonferrous
plant Umicore was indicated as a local source of SO2.
For
particulate matter (PM) the distribution of ionic compounds in different PM
fractions was assessed, indicating that the water-soluble ions NH4+
and NO3-, and Cl- and Na+ occurred
mainly in particles with an aerodynamic diameter smaller than 1 µm. The most
abundant water-soluble ions were NO3- and SO42-.
Furthermore, in a case study in Menen, nearby the Belgian frontier of France,
the bulk elemental and the water-soluble ion concentrations in PM2.5
were assessed. It was concluded that the aerosol composition in Menen was a
function of local, meteorological and seasonal circumstances; however an
important influence occurred through cross-boundery air pollution, originating
mainly from Germany and the U.K., which mainly affected the anthropogenic
elements in PM2.5.
In
spite of the attention which is generally drawn to outdoor air pollution,
several international studies have emphasised the importance of the indoor air
quality, since increased indoor levels of certain contaminants have been
reported in comparison to the ambient levels. Moreover, considering the fact
that people spend on average 80% of their time indoors, the indoor environment
has been indicated to be a more suitable estimator of personal exposures. In a
limited number of countries, indoor air quality guidelines have been formulated
as it is, since very recently, the case for Belgium. Two case studies were
organised in which a set of particulate and gaseous air pollutants was monitored
inside houses and schools (classroom and on the playground) in Antwerp and its
southern suburbs. Parallel outdoor measurements were performed to assess the
relation between indoor and outdoor air quality. The first case-study was
performed in 19 houses in Antwerp, aiming to determine the relation between the
indoor and outdoor air quality, and to identify indoor sources typical to
residential buildings. Additional attention was paid to the personal exposure to
gas-phase pollutants of one of the inhabitants of each house. The second study
assessed the indoor air quality of 27 primary schools in the city centre of
Antwerp and its southern suburbs, with the specific aim to investigate the
real-time daily exposure of 7 to 8 year old school children. Attention was paid
to the concentrations of air pollutants with recognized potentials to cause
adverse health effects, such as the gas-phase compounds NO2, SO2,
O3, HAc, HFor and BTEX and respirable particulate matter (PM2.5).
Furthermore the elemental composition and elemental C content of PM2.5
were determined.
In
residential air, tobacco smoke was identified as being a major source of indoor
PM mass concentrations and was most enriched in the smallest particle size
fractions (PM1). According to this case study the indoor occurrence
of the elements in houses (metals, Cl and S) mainly originated from outdoor
sources. A study of the elemental indoor/outdoor ratios in the houses indicated
a unique micro-environment for each residence. The major indoor source of NO2
formation was gas cooking. Indoor gases without major indoor sources were
strongly correlated to ambient air. Nevertheless, the personal exposure to
gaseous compounds showed a highly significant linear relationship with the
indoor air and only poor or no correlations were identified with ambient air.
These findings confirmed the previously formulated hypothesis, which stated that
each house is characterized by its own micro-environment. Consequently, the
indoor air quality of residences cannot be estimated by the use of a fixed
ambient air monitoring site.
In
the second case study, which was organised in 27 primary schools, much attention
was paid to correlations between indoor and ambient air, in order to test the
hypothesis that a strong correlation between indoor, ambient and consequently
fixed monitor air pollutant levels would exist, which could then be used to
support the use of a fixed monitoring site as a good estimator for personal
exposure. It was found that only in the cases of BS, NO2, SO2
and O3, such correlations could be established. However, due to their
different deposition velocities and decomposition rates in indoor air, the
respective I/O ratios of the gases varied considerably, decreasing in the
sequence NO2, SO2 and O3. Concerning PM2.5
mass concentrations, BTEX, HAc and HFor, no correlation was established between
the classroom and the outdoor levels, except for benzene. In spite of the fact
that also for these pollutants no indoor sources were expected to be present
inside the classrooms, they occurred at I/O ratios exceeding unity. For BTEX the
most elevated I/O ratios were identified for toluene, followed by ethylbenzene
and the xylene isomers. The highest I/O values were identified for HAc and HFor.
Classroom PM2.5 occurred at different mass concentrations and with a
different elemental composition than ambient PM2.5. In fact, the
indoor mass concentrations were considerably influenced by re-suspension as a
consequence of the room occupation, leading to an increased dust contribution to
indoor PM2.5. The presence of carpets inside of the classrooms was
identified as having a significant influence on the I/O ratios.
In
general, the use of ambient air pollutant concentrations as estimators of the
indoor air quality, and consequently of personal exposures inside classrooms in
the city of Antwerp and its southern suburbs, would lead to an overestimation of
the exposures to NO2, SO2 and O3 and an
underestimation of the exposure to PM2.5, BTEX, HAc and HFor. Thus,
neither the ambient air concentrations, nor the fixed site measurements provide
an accurate estimation of the children’s personal exposures to the identified
air pollutants inside the classrooms. Of course one has to notice that the
extent, to which the indoor air quality of a child’s classroom can be used as
an indicator of its personal exposure, is strongly dependent of the child’s
indoor residential air quality. As concluded in the residential air case study,
e.g. parental smoking would cause highly elevated PM2.5 levels inside
the house, which would then diminish the effect of the contribution of the
classroom air quality to the child’s total personal exposure. In the ideal
case, personal monitoring combined with indoor and outdoor monitoring in the
child’s home and classroom would give a decisive answer to this question.
Unfortunately, the large dimensions of the sampling program in such a case would
not allow its practical realisation.
The results of this study highlight the importance of the assessment of the indoor air quality in different environmental settings. Moreover it confirms the large variations between various indoor micro-environments and their differences from the ambient air quality. This work emphasises the importance and the urgency of a profound understanding of the impact of air pollution on human health. As for PM2.5, scientists did not conclude yet whether the adverse health effects are caused by its composition or by its mass concentration. Furthermore, this study also stresses the value of a detailed indoor air quality legislation, which assigns limit values at reasonable, practical measurable and meaningful averaging times. Only then the indoor air quality can be evaluated and, if necessary, actions can be undertaken to reduce the indoor pollutant levels.
Polycyclic Aromatic Hydrocarbons in the atmosphere: Fast determination, concentrations, sources and health risks. KHAIWAL RAVINDRA, 2006
The Polycyclic Aromatic Hydrocarbons (PAHs) have gained attention due to their ubiquitous presence in different environments and being the first atmospheric pollutants to have been identified as suspected carcinogen. Considering this the health risk associated with the various size fractions of suspended particles with special reference to PAHs was reviewed. Some exposure studies to PAHs were appraised and the prevalence of different PAHs at selected global sites were also compared. The various known sources of PAHs and their formation were also studied to identify and characterize the emission sources of PAHs.
Environmental analysis requires PAHs levels to be determined faster than the conventional methods and at less cost. The approach of pressured liquid extraction (PLE) was evaluated for fast extraction of PAHs and to reduce the amount of toxic solvents. Further, a method was developed using low pressure gas chromatography – ion trap mass spectrometry (LPGC-ITMS) for the fast analysis of PAHs in environmental samples. The method reduces the analysis time by three factors but results in limited loss of separation power compared to that of conventional GC-MS due the occurrence of three critical pairs for high-molecular weight PAHs.
The limitation of LPGC-ITMS motivated the use of high performance liquid chromatography (HPLC) for the analysis of PAHs samples collected from various cities of Flanders. The site-specific variation in vapor and aerosol PAHs was assessed and the application of diagnostic ratio and principal component analysis (PCA) was applied to identify and characterize their emission sources. The influences of meteorological parameters on PAHs levels as well as the potential toxic fraction of PAHs in ambient air of Flanders were also calculated. The impacts of regional and global activities on PAHs levels provide useful information for the regulation and control of PAHs in Europe.
The water soluble fraction (WSF) mostly consists of ionic compounds and can comprise up to 60-70 % of total particulate mass. The WSF components may increase the solubility of toxic organic compounds, such as n-alkanes and PAHs by acting as surface active agents and hence the WSF of PM2.5 was identified and the relation to gaseous pollutants was studied. Finally, a case study of Delhi (India), where to improve the air quality the entire public transport was amended to use compressed natural gas (CNG), was assessed. The CNG is considered to be clean fuel and hence emits less pollutants.
Characterization of indoor gaseous and particulate pollutants for conservation in museums and churches. VELICHKA KONTOZOVA-DEUTSCH, 2007
This study is focused on the environmental analysis of gaseous and particulate air pollutants in the context of the conservation of our Cultural Heritage. A variety of analytical techniques has been applied to the different types of samples. The first main topic of this work deals with the investigation of the concentration of pollutant gases and the chemical composition of fine particulate matter for the conservation of ancient stained glass windows in several famous European cathedrals and churches. The second main topic is related to the determination of outdoor and indoor generated gaseous and particulate air pollutants for the preservation of museum objects in galleries and showcases of eight museums.
In Chapter I of this dissertation atmospheric gaseous and particulate air pollutants are discussed in detail. Special attention is given to air pollutants that are potentially harmful for Cultural Heritage objects. Among the pollutants with mainly outdoor sources, NOx, SO2, O3 as well as primary and secondary particulate matter is described. The main indoor generated air pollutants of interest in this work are formic and acetic acid. The most important sources and characteristics are mentioned. The chemical composition of atmospheric particulate matter is also elucidated.
Subsequently, special attention is given to Indoor Air Quality (IAQ) and factors influencing IAQ. Damage to works of art can raise from a variety of processes, including soiling by particles and chemical attack by aggressive air pollutants, but also e.g. by hygrometric stress or by biodegradation. A short overview on these processes is given. Among others e.g. the influence of the air exchange rate between indoor and outdoor air and the deposition of particulate matter to museum object surfaces is discussed. Finally the basic principles of the preservation of works of art are explained, including the assessment of the risk of deterioration of objects and possible control strategies for objects displayed in galleries and in showcases.
Chapter II gives an overview of the analytical techniques used in the framework of this dissertation. The sampling equipment comprised passive diffusion tubes from different manufacturers for the sampling of the gaseous pollutants NO2, SO2, O3, formic acid and acetic acid as well as instrumentation for the sampling of atmospheric particulate matter. Bulk particles were sampled on membrane filters whereas different kinds of cascade impactors were used for the size-fractionated sampling of particles.
Ion Chromatography (IC) was applied for the determination of the compounds sampled by means of the diffusive samplers and for the investigation of water soluble compounds in aerosol particles and efflorescence crystals collected from museum objects. Bulk elemental concentrations in aerosol particles were determined by energy dispersive X-ray fluorescence (EDXRF) analysis. A large number of samples was investigated by automated single particle analysis by means of electron probe microanalysis (EPMA). Finally, samples were also analyzed with Micro Raman Spectrometry. The main advantages and disadvantages of these techniques with respect to the samples analyzed in this work are discussed.
Chapter
III of this work deals with the sampling and analysis of gaseous and
particulate air pollutants in three European cathedrals with the aim to assess
the environmental conditions of ancient stained glass windows with and without
protective glazing. The Basilica Saint-Urbain in
Before discussing the obtained results, the composition and structure of stained glass and the glass paint (grisaille) is explained. Special attention is given to the mechanisms of glass weathering, especially under the influence of aggressive gases and aerosol particles. Additionally, the different types of (protective) double glazing systems along with their characteristics are presented.
Sampling at the three cathedrals was always carried out at several locations in the outdoor air as well as in the indoor air and inside the interspace between the historic stained glass and the protective glazing. The results from the Basilica Saint-Urbain in Troyes showed that both SO2 and O3 had much lower concentrations inside the Basilica than outside during the whole year, whereas NO2 showed significantly higher indoor concentrations, which were with high probability due to burning candles in the church. CO2-levels inside the church clearly reflected the amount of people present inside - the highest concentrations were detected on Christmas Eve and during All Saints.
The
results for the particulate air pollutants show that the average indoor and
outdoor concentrations of all investigated elements for all sampling campaigns
were rather similar. However, different Indoor/Outdoor-ratios were found for the
different sampling campaigns. The single particle analysis showed the highest
abundances for soil dust particles, organic particles, CaCO3-particles
and NH4NO3-particles. Soil dust particles are not
aggressive for the glass, but they cause soiling of the windows. Organic
particles instead have to be considered as potentially dangerous because they
can enhance the adsorption of aggressive compounds to the glass. Ammonium
nitrate particles are also dangerous for the glass because of their hygroscopic
nature. They can provoke condensation of water vapour on surfaces where these
particles are deposited. Subsequently, aggressive ions are released into the
solution and gases and other particles are deposited much faster on the wet
glass surface leading to an enhanced attack of the glass. In general, higher
abundances of organic particles and nitrates were observed indoors in comparison
to outdoors. Hence, it can be concluded that the protective glazing in the
Basilica Saint-Urbain is predominantly advantageous (except for NO2)
from the gases’ point of view, but it is only fairly advantageous from the
particles’ point of view.
The
investigations at the Sainte Chapelle, which is included into UNESCO’s list of
World Cultural Heritage, showed that the concentrations of NO2, SO2
and O3 were always higher in the outdoor air than in the indoor air.
However, in comparison to the Basilica Saint-Urbain in
As far as the particulate matter concentrations are concerned, significantly higher indoor concentrations were found for all investigated elements in comparison to the outdoor concentrations. The main reason for this observation has to be seen in the high number of visitors in the Sainte Chapelle. The visitors enter the Sainte Chapelle and introduce with them rather large amounts of particles from outside attached to their shoes and clothes. These particles are released inside the building when the visitors walk around and are resuspended by them. Single particle analysis revealed again soil dust particles, organic particles, CaCO3-particles and CaSO4-particles. Interestingly the latter type of particles was only found inside the Sainte Chapelle which could be due to their formation in the indoor environment from CaCO3 and SO2 which was present in rather high concentrations. The chemical composition of the particles collected from the interspace was close to the one of the particles collected indoors. To conclude, the protective glazing can be considered as advantageous from the gases’ point of view, whereas it can not be considered as advantageous from the particles’ point of view with respect to the high indoor concentrations of particulate matter.
The
results from the investigations in the Cathedral of Cologne were generally
rather similar to the ones from the Basilica Saint-Urbain in
Single
particle analysis of the samples from
Chapter IV focuses on the characterization of indoor and outdoor generated air pollutants in eight museums. As an introduction to airborne pollutants in museums, an overview is given on the most important pollutants in museums along with their sources and their effects on works of art. The different methods for the quantification of the exposure-effect relationship for Cultural Heritage objects are shown as well. Using the “no observed adverse effect level” (NOAEL) and the “lowest observed adverse effect dose” (LOAED), maximum permitted pollutant concentrations were calculated for different kinds of object materials and for certain preservation targets, i.e. periods of time during which no adverse effect may occur. Another point of interest is the damage of the surface of museum objects due to the formation of efflorescence.
The
museums investigated in this work are situated in
Sampling was carried out at all locations following the same principles as described before for the sampling in the cathedrals. Samples of gaseous and particulate air pollutants were always taken in the outdoor air as well as indoors. Special attention was given to the aggressive pollutants acetic acid and formic acid.
In
all investigated museums, the concentrations of the mainly outdoor generated
pollutant gases NO2, SO2 and O3 were found to
be reduced in the indoor environment, as there were no significant indoor
sources of NO2 present. For SO2 and O3, the
most significant reduction in concentrations was found in the galleries in
comparison to the outdoor values, as both gases have rather high deposition
velocities to a large range of indoor surface materials. For NO2
instead the concentrations were mainly reduced inside museum showcases in
comparison to the galleries, as NO2 does not deposit as fast as SO2
and O3. The concentration ratios between the outdoor air and the air
in the galleries depended mainly on the extent of ventilation of the galleries.
The two museums with a heating, ventilation and air conditioning system (HVAC)
being operative throughout all the galleries had by far the highest I/O-ratios
for NO2 of all investigated museums.
Generally, inside showcases and other more or less sealed enclosures, the concentrations of SO2 and O3 were very low. For NO2, the ratio between the concentration inside a showcase and in the gallery depended mainly on the extent of ventilation of the showcase. Apart from the ventilation rates of the showcases also the construction materials used for the showcases play an important role for the showcase/gallery concentration ratio. Showcases made entirely from metal and glass (as some of the showcases investigated in the Metropolitan Museum of Art) showed the highest showcase/gallery concentration ratio as the pollutants deposit only very slowly onto these materials.
In contrast, formic acid and acetic acid were generally detected in much higher concentrations in the indoor air in comparison to outdoor concentrations. By far the highest organic acid concentrations were found inside showcases made from wood or composite products containing wood. Also showcases with wooden objects of art showed an enrichment with organic acids in the inside air. These materials emit rather large amounts of formic and especially acetic acid. However, huge differences were observed between different types of showcases according to their ventilation and the construction materials used. An accumulation of acetic acid to a concentration of more than 1 mg/m3 was observed exclusively due to the emissions of wooden objects of art themselves. In showcases constructed from wood composite products, acetic acid concentrations of even up to 6 mg/m3 were observed.
When comparing the observed concentrations of NO2, SO2, O3 and acetic acid from this work with the maximum permitted pollutant concentrations calculated from the NOAEL- and LOAED-values of the different pollutant/material-pairs, it can be concluded that actual concentrations of air pollutants inside museums often exceed the maximum tolerable concentrations by far. For NO2, even a preservation target of only 10 years is currently not reached for a lot of objects displayed in the galleries. However, it is reached in part of the investigated display cases. For O3, a preservation target of 10 years is reached in part of the galleries, but a target of 100 years is reached almost never. Inside showcases, the situation is again better. SO2 profits from the serious decrease in ambient concentrations during the last decades and a preservation target of 10 years is reached for a lot of galleries and most of the showcases. Instead, acetic acid forms a serious problem in all investigated museums except for the Metropolitan Museum of Art. Inside most of the investigated showcases, acetic acid concentrations were high enough in order damage to occur within a time period of less than ten years. Several objects with a visible degradation due to the formation of efflorescence on the object’s surface were found and the chemical composition of the crystals was investigated. At least at one location the presence of an acetate salt on the material’s surface could be confirmed, proving the important role of acetic acid in the deterioration of museum objects.
The obtained results show that museum showcases protect works of art from aggressive outdoor generated air pollutants, but on the other hand they can accumulate high concentrations of dangerous formic and acetic acid. Depending on the kind of pollutant being especially dangerous for a certain object of art, the display in a showcase can improve, but also deteriorate the conditions for its conservation. Very different situations can be encountered between locations and no universal advice can be given to conservators. Nevertheless some basic principles and often reoccurring problems in Cultural Heritage environments could be identified in this work.
Application of high-energy polarized-beam energy-dispersive X-ray fluorescence for industrial and environmental purposes. KATLEEN VAN MEEL, 2009
Throughout this work, EDXRF methods for various applications have been developed. The secondary target set-up not only proved to be very useful to obtain a low background due to polarization, but it is a real asset to the versatility of the spectrometer. Not only does it allow improved sensitivity, but it also enables selective excitation. Furthermore, a combination with high excitation energy (up to 100 kV) and a suitable detector performance in the high energy region, extents the application range for high-Z elements compared to conventional EDXRF.
High-Z elements such as precious metals or heavy metals are often difficult to detect with conventional EDXRF. Due to lack of excitation energy, anode material and decreasing detection capacities in the high-energy range, conventional EDXRF is usually limited to L-lines for the determination of elements with Z starting from around 40. L-line spectra are more complicated than K-lines and there is an increased risk for overlapping, e.g. the L-lines of Cd, In and Sb may overlap with the K-lines of Ca as well as with each other. In environmental soil samples it is easy to imagine that this may cause problems when e.g. dealing with Ca-rich soils. However, with the high-energy secondary-target EDXRF spectrometer, K-lines can be used for elements up to tungsten (Z = 74) and this problem is easily overcome.
The performance of the spectrometer is in some cases comparable or even better than classical reference techniques. The precious metals used in ACCs (Pt, Pd and Rh) can be determined in this matrix with equal precision and accuracy as the reference ICP-OES method. On top of this, the EDXRF procedure has the benefit of being cheaper and faster. Detection limits of around 5 ppm for this application (for a 500 s irradiation) demonstrate the improved sensitivity due to proper secondary target choice. In heavier matrices such as NiS-beads the technique is still applicable, but the performance is less spectacular. The method is faster and cheaper than an ICP-OES method, which requires an additional digestion and co-precipitation step, but the detection limits are not competitive in all materials due to large dilution (30 times or more). In very complex matrices, on the other hand, not even the secondary targets can provide an easy one-preparation-only solution for the determination of all elements.
Also in environmental applications, the improved spectrometer can provide elegant solutions for delicate analysis. Thin film analyses are very straightforward on EDXRF devices. This sample preparation can be used for e.g. air and water analysis. Aerosol filters already have low backgrounds for conventional EDXRF, but the polarizing geometry of the spectrometer provides a practically horizontal background for most secondary targets, allowing even lower detection limits than before. The higher energy and the extended applicability of the K-lines also enable better detection of harmful heavy metals and detection limits of a few ng/m³ are achieved. Determination of Cd in saline solutions is often difficult and preconcentration on a thin film sample (membrane) can offer an easy and cheap solution. The obtained detection limit, 700 ppb, is competitive with other reference methods such as ETAAS and ICP-AES. In the sediment fingerprinting application field, heavy and rare earth elements (such as e.g. Ce) can be interesting tracers, making it desirable to be able to detect them at low levels. A robust method has been optimized for the determination of a large variety of elements in Belgian soils and sediments, using a combination of SRMs and secondary standards for the calibration.
The applied spectrometer is a versatile instrument that can be used for a manifold of substances and topics. The performance is excellent and often competitive with traditional reference techniques, on which sample preparation and analysis tend to be more expensive and time-consuming.